DHS Considers Reality Show Where Immigrants Compete for Citizenship

A Shocking Pitch: Turning Immigration Into Entertainment?

In an unexpected twist that’s sparking national debate, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is reportedly reviewing a pitch for a reality television show in which undocumented immigrants would compete for a chance to win American citizenship.

The proposed show—tentatively titled “The American”—was submitted by Canadian TV producer Rob Worsoff, known for his work on shows like Duck Dynasty. According to the pitch, twelve immigrants would participate in a series of patriotic and culturally themed challenges. The grand prize? U.S. citizenship granted in a ceremonial event held at the Capitol.

Who’s Behind the Proposal?

Worsoff’s goal, he claims, is to "highlight patriotism" and provide viewers with a better understanding of the naturalization process. In an interview with The Daily Beast, he emphasized that no participant would face deportation for losing, describing the show as “uplifting” and “educational.”

However, many critics are unconvinced.

DHS Responds: “Too Early to Say”

While the DHS has confirmed receiving the proposal, a spokesperson clarified that the idea is only in the early review phase. There is no formal approval or endorsement. Furthermore, claims that South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem supported the project were denied by DHS, calling those reports inaccurate.

This hasn't stopped the public backlash.

Critics Call It “Cruel and Exploitative”

The concept of gamifying immigration—an already emotionally and legally complex process—has raised serious ethical concerns.

• Some compare it to The Hunger Games, where real people are placed in competitive scenarios for entertainment.
• Immigrant rights advocates argue it trivializes the sacrifices and struggles of millions trying to legalize their status.
• Others question whether citizenship should ever be tied to public spectacle.

Why This Story Matters

This proposal isn’t just about TV—it’s about how we as a country view immigration and immigrants. Turning life-altering decisions into spectacle may attract viewers, but it risks damaging public perception and alienating the very people the U.S. aims to integrate.

At a time when immigration policy is already deeply politicized, the idea of a “citizenship competition” strikes many as inappropriate and deeply insensitive.

Final Thoughts

While “The American” remains just a proposal, the fact that such an idea made its way to the Department of Homeland Security reflects a growing trend: blurring the lines between entertainment, policy, and people’s lives.

The debate continues—and it's one we can't afford to ignore.

Key Takeaways

• DHS confirmed receipt of a reality TV proposal called The American.
• The show would have undocumented immigrants compete for U.S. citizenship.
• Public reaction is deeply polarized—some call it educational, others call it exploitative.
• The proposal is still under review, with no approval granted yet.